I've had so many women reach out recently, asking about what I've read or heard about hormone therapy, so I thought it was time to share what I know.

If this is something you've wondered about, I hope today's newsletter will help answer some questions.

If it's something you're considering, it's best to "shop around" for the right hormone doctor, one who understands both natural and pharmaceutical solutions for helping patients optimize their hormones and health.

Here we go...

Few health topics spark as much confusion (and controversy) as bioidentical hormone replacement therapy (bHRT).

For every woman who swears bHRT saved her life, there’s another who’s terrified to even consider it—because she’s been told it will increase her risk of cancer, blood clots, or some other life-threatening issue.

So what’s the truth?

Are bioidentical hormones a safe, effective solution for balancing hormones and reducing menopause symptoms?

Or are they just as risky as conventional hormone therapy (or worse, as some doctors claim)?

Today, we’re clearing up the confusion—what bHRT is, how it works, and why the controversy exists in the first place.

Let’s get into it.

What Are Bioidentical Hormones?

Bioidentical hormones are molecularly identical to the hormones your body naturally produces.

Unlike synthetic hormones—like those used in traditional hormone replacement therapy (HRT)—bioidentical hormones match your body’s natural hormones exactly.

That means your body recognizes and processes them just like it would its own estrogen, progesterone, and testosterone.

But here’s where it gets tricky…

Most people (and many doctors, unfortunately) lump bioidentical hormones together with synthetic hormones—assuming they carry the same risks.

This is a massive mistake.

The WHI Study: How One Study Misled Millions

The confusion around hormone therapy started with the Women’s Health Initiative (WHI) study in 2002.

This was a large clinical trial designed to examine the effects of synthetic hormone therapy in postmenopausal women.

Here’s what happened:

❌ The study found an increased risk of breast cancer, heart disease, strokes, and blood clots in women taking Prempro—a synthetic estrogen-progestin drug.
❌ The media ran with the findings, declaring "hormones cause cancer and heart disease!"​
❌ Millions of women stopped hormone therapy overnight—many suffering severe menopause symptoms and health declines as a result.

But there were two major problems with how the study was reported:

1️⃣ The WHI study used synthetic hormones (Premarin and Provera)—which are not the same as bioidentical hormones.
2️⃣ The increased risks were primarily in older women (who started HRT 10+ years after menopause), not in women who started hormone therapy earlier.

Translation?

The study didn’t actually prove that bioidentical hormones are dangerous—it only showed risks associated with synthetic, non-bioidentical hormones.

Yet, even today, many doctors still cite the WHI study as a reason to avoid all hormone therapy, including bHRT.

So, Are Bioidentical Hormones Safe?

Here’s what the latest research says:

✅ Bioidentical hormones are safer than synthetic hormones. Studies show lower risks of blood clots, strokes, and breast cancer compared to synthetic HRT.

✅ bHRT is beneficial when started early. Women who start bioidentical hormone therapy within 5-10 years of menopause often see significant health benefits with minimal risk.

✅ bHRT can reduce the risk of osteoporosis, cognitive decline, and heart disease. Estrogen is protective for bone density, brain function, and cardiovascular health.

✅ Topical and transdermal estrogens (creams, patches, and pellets) have lower risks than oral estrogen.

• Estrogen pills increase clot risk more than creams, pellets, or patches.
• Pellets provide a steady hormone release, avoiding fluctuations that can happen with creams and oral forms.

So, in proper doses and under medical supervision, bHRT can be a safe, effective option for hormone balance.

What About Cancer Risk?

The biggest fear around hormone therapy is breast cancer.

Here’s the truth:

🔹 Estrogen alone (without synthetic progestins) does NOT increase breast cancer risk.​
🔹 Bioidentical progesterone (not synthetic progestins) does NOT raise breast cancer risk.​
🔹 The real problem? Synthetic progestins—which were used in the WHI study and are NOT the same as bioidentical progesterone.

In fact, some studies suggest bioidentical progesterone may even be protective against breast cancer.

So why do so many doctors still warn against hormone therapy?​
Because they’re still relying on outdated research and failing to distinguish between synthetic and bioidentical hormones.

Who Should Consider Bioidentical Hormones?

If you’re dealing with:

✔ Severe menopause symptoms (hot flashes, night sweats, mood swings, insomnia)
✔ Low libido and vaginal dryness​
✔ Brain fog and memory issues​
✔ Chronic fatigue and energy crashes​
✔ Osteopenia or osteoporosis risk​
✔ Unexplained weight gain and metabolic slowdowns

…bHRT could be worth discussing with an integrative doctor.

The Right (and Wrong) Way to Use bHRT

If you’re considering bioidentical hormone therapy, here’s what you need to know:

✅ Get Comprehensive Testing First – Don’t just guess—work with a hormone-literate doctor who tests estrogen, progesterone, testosterone, DHEA, and cortisol.

✅ Start with the Lowest Effective Dose – More isn’t always better. The goal is to restore balance, not overload your system.

✅ Use the Right Form – Transdermal (cream or patch) is safer than oral estrogen.

• Pellets can be an option for women who prefer a steady, long-lasting hormone release. However, pellet dosing needs to be carefully monitored, as levels can sometimes fluctuate.

✅ Monitor Your Hormones Regularly – Levels change, and so should your dosing. Retest every 6-12 months for adjustments.

🚫 Avoid Synthetic Hormones – If your doctor suggests Provera, Premarin, or synthetic progestins, run the other way.

🚫 Don’t Get Your Info from Mainstream Media – Most articles still rely on outdated WHI study fears. Look at the latest research.

Bioidentical Hormones Aren’t “Anti-Aging Magic,” But…

They can be a game-changer for women struggling with hormone imbalance—when used correctly.

The problem is, too many doctors are still stuck in 2002, warning women off hormone therapy based on outdated, flawed research.

So if you’re considering bHRT?

✔ Do your own research.
✔ Find a doctor who understands bioidentical—not synthetic—hormones.​
✔ Make decisions based on your personal health, not fear-mongering headlines.

In faith, fitness, and fortitude, Tom Nikkola, CSCS

​​

​Catch up on previous Nikkola Newsletters here.